“He who holds Stirling, holds Scotland”. The quote refers to Stirling Castle, which was the center of Scottish history for centuries. The castle was all but impregnable, surrounded on 3 sides by nearly vertical rock cliffs with sweeping “I can see forever” views. The castle’s importance, however, was due to those sweeping views overlooking a bridge over the River Forth, the primary passage between the Lowlands and Highlands. Due to its strategic location and invincible fortifications, it was both a focus for conquest and a safe refuge for royalty. So much history occurred around this castle that I would be remiss not to mention some. I promise a rather quick sketch. In depth, the history reads like a trashy novel – victories, banishment, plotted returns, intrigues, murder, assassinations, a son waging war (and killing) a father, imprisonments, escapes, revolts, beheadings …. The kings led interesting, if short, lives. We won’t go there (much), though – just a bit of history of the castle. This will be a long post, so feel free to skip to the pictures that follow! However, I think the history provides very useful context.
Stirling Castle’s written history began in 843, when an historian noted that Kenneth MacAlpin, the first King of Scotland, besieged Stirling Castle during his successful fight to unite the Picts and Scots into the kingdom now known as Scotland. At some point it became the home of Scottish royalty; in 1110 King Alexander I dedicated a royal chapel there, and his successor King David I made Stirling itself a royal city. Skirmishes with England became common, and Stirling Castle was the football. In 1174 the Scottish King William I invaded England but was captured at Alnwick (Alnwick Castle, February 14, 2015); to gain his freedom he ceded Stirling Castle to English King Henry II. In 1189 he got it back when English King Richard I came to the throne. Then came the Wars of Scottish Independence, which lasted for 60 years. The outline below shows how the war centered around Stirling Castle. Notice how the castle ping-pongs between the two countries!!
1296 – Stirling Castle was captured by English King Edward I.
1297 – The Scot William Wallace (a.k.a. Braveheart) defeated a superior English force at the Battle of Stirling Bridge (within sight of Stirling Castle) and later that year took back the castle following a siege.
1298 – William Wallace was defeated at the Battle of Falkirk, and the English reclaimed Stirling Castle.
1299 – The English surrendered the castle to the Scots following a siege.
1304 – English King Edward I waged war on Scotland for years; Stirling Castle was the last stronghold; it was besieged and bombarded by 17 siege engines for 4 months. When a massive trebuchet was built (“War Wolf”) capable of hurling missiles weighing 300 lbs, the Scots surrendered and the English controlled it for 10 years.
1314 – King of Scotland Robert the Bruce (Robert I) retook the castle by beating the 3X larger English army of Edward II at the Battle of Bannockburn just outside the Stirling Castle walls.
1336 – Stirling Castle was captured by the English
1337 – A siege of Stirling Castle by the Scots was unsuccessful
1342 – The future Scottish King Robert Stewart (Robert II) retook Stirling Castle in a successful siege. The castle remained Scottish until the end of the war in 1357.
Two of those battles, the victories of the plucky Scots under William Wallace in 1297 and Robert the Bruce in 1314, both against huge odds, remain a source of fierce pride in a Scotland that still questions its English union.
Before visiting the castle, a little more history (but 400 years worth!) is worthwhile. The Stewart kings Robert II and III made Stirling Castle their primary residence. It’s from Robert II’s time that the earliest surviving parts of the castle were built – the foundations of the North Gate, built in the 1380’s. King James I ascended the throne (then was caught and imprisoned by the English, saw a beautiful lady from his tower prison, wrote a poem about her [The King’s Quair] that we all read in high school, married her [cousin to English King Henry IV], and was released), but was assassinated in 1437, whereupon his queen smuggled son James II into Stirling Castle for safekeeping. James III was born in Stirling Castle and favored it as his “most pleasant residence” (he was killed in a revolt led by his son James IV). During the reign of James IV and V, 1490 – 1560 (and beyond), the city entered its golden age; Stirling became the principal royal center. Almost all the present buildings in the castle were constructed, in grand style, turning the castle into the showpiece of Scotland (i.e., one-upmanship over England). With James IV’s death, James V was crowned in the royal chapel of Stirling Castle (at age 17 months). He married the French noblewoman Mary of Guise and had a daughter Mary Queen of Scots. When James V died, Mary of Guise became Regent of Scotland; with nobles scrambling for power, she brought her daughter Mary to Stirling Castle for safekeeping behind strong walls (she came with 2,500 cavalry, 1,000 infantry, and a baggage train a mile long). Mary Queen of Scots was crowned (as an infant) in Stirling Castle and spent her early years there, subsequently going to France. In the face of threats from England, French troops were brought in and the outer defenses of Stirling Castle were built. Mary Queen of Scots returned to Stirling Castle, wed, and had a son there, James VI (responsible for the King James version of the Bible) in 1567. The Catholic Mary’s estranged husband was mysteriously murdered, she remarried, there was an uprising, and she was abducted to England and held captive by Queen Elizabeth I. With various factions plotting for power, Mary was forced to abdicate to James VI, who was crowned king at age 9 months, raised in the safety of Stirling Castle as Protestant, and turned against his Catholic mother. Stirling Castle became the base for James supporters, Edinburgh for Mary’s. Attacks were made against Stirling Castle, but failed. Mary was eventually executed by Queen Elizabeth I. When Queen Elizabeth died without an heir in 1603, King James VI of Scotland became King James I of a united Scotland and England. He left for London, returning to Scotland only once, briefly, after 14 years. With his absence, Stirling’s role as a royal residence declined, and Stirling Castle became principally a military center and a prison. When James VI died in 1625, the son Charles I inherited a kingdom divided by religion and throne pretenders. His efforts to impose English liturgy on Scotland led to war – and his beheading, with Scotland choosing son Charles II as their king, who lived in Sterling Castle in 1640, while England got Oliver Cromwell, who turned England into a Republic. Charles II marched against Cromwell and was defeated; Cromwell’s forces successfully besieged Stirling Castle in 1651, inflicting still-visible shot marks within the Castle. Charles II fled, but returned as King of England and Scotland a decade later when Cromwell died and the English monarchy was restored. Religious tension grew, and Charles’ attempted to introduce religious freedom for Catholics was unsuccessful. When Charles II died and his Catholic brother James VII (English James II) not only ascended the throne but subsequently produced a Catholic heir, war broke out; James, the last Catholic King of England and Scotland, was forced to flee in 1688 and Protestants (William and Mary) assumed the throne. James continued to claim the thrones of England and Scotland from exile in France and encouraged revolts in his name (Jacobite Rebellions). His grandson the Bonnie Prince Charlie led an ultimately unsuccessful uprising in 1745; the Bonnie Prince bypassed Stirling and captured Edinburgh, but returning to Stirling in 1746 he was unable to capture Stirling Castle. This was the last time that Stirling Castle was besieged. The Bonnie Prince’s subsequent defeat ended any chance of Catholicism becoming re-established in England.
Wow! A lot of history swirled around this castle. Let’s take a look at it (finally, eh?). This picture is an artist’s impression of the grand entrance to James IV castle, based on a detail from a Scottish map done in the late 1500’s; the gate was among the most magnificent in the UK. When it was constructed, it both strengthened the castle’s defenses and projected the greatness of James himself. The gate was probably reached by wooden bridge over a moat. This original gate was higher than the current one; it had 5-story towers capped with conical roofs, and was probably coated in gold limewash, with carved details painted and gilded.
The first detailed drawing of Stirling Castle comes courtesy of a military engineer in 1671, although the view is not from the gate.
Today the entrance to the castle – the old castle interior – looks like the illustration shown just below, with the buildings built by James IV and V peeking above the wall. Comparing this picture with that from the 1500’s above, the current gate is clearly less grand and more military-looking, reflecting its changed role after the departure of James VI (and the impact of siege bombardments!).
The main entrance to Stirling Castle now takes you into the extensive outer defenses, built by Protestant Queen Anne (daughter of deposed Catholic James VII) in 1708 after her half-brother contested the crown. This map of the Stirling Castle fortress shown on the left is a good overview. The original entrance to the castle, now called the “Forework”, is just below the center of the picture. The current entrance to the outer defenses is at the bottom left. That entrance is shown in the pictures below. The entrance takes you to a
courtyard holding pen, with another gate that takes you to the front of the original castle, shown below. Turning left after going through that second entrance (the map of Stirling Castle, above, provides a useful overview), one comes to a formal garden/green called the Queen Anne Garden, shown below, although it was already there in the 1400’s for the royal family to enjoy. You can begin
to see the amazing vista that the castle provides, so let’s take a look around. It’s
impressive, and many of the important battles of Scotland would have been visible from here. You will also note, from the map of the Stirling Castle above, that there are a number of cannon that look out over this vista; those cannon were instrumental in blowing up siege towers in later years.
OK, in we go through what used to be the grand entrance to the castle. It definitely looks more military than grand! The entrance takes us into the “Outer Close” – and mostly to a view of the back ends of the major buildings, the royal palace and the great hall, as well as going downhill to the “Great Kitchens” of the palace.
The Outer Close also had an interesting exhibit on the food of the late 1400’s – as you might imagine, it’s not too different from today.
The Inner Close was the core of Stirling Castle in the 1100’s and continued to be its center (the map of Stirling Castle is again useful). In its golden age it was surrounded by the trappings of royalty, consisting of the King’s Old Building (private apartments of James IV, 1496), the Great Hall (used for banquets and business, 1503), Royal Palace (built by James V for greater luxury and privacy, 1540), and Chapel Royal (built by James VI for the baptism of his first son, 1594). These buildings have been restored from their military conversions.
James V built the Royal Palace in grand style, on par with the finest French chateau, in order to impress and “proclaim the peace, prosperity and justice of his reign”. Here’s what the outside looks like today, and what it would have looked like in 1540:
James V decorated the outside of the palace with over 250 sculptures, including classic gods and goddesses, designed to promote his authority and demonstrate his right to rule. The statues have weathered (and suffered indignities) over the centuries, but they were clearly nicely done; examples below. The last picture shows how they would have looked back in the day.
The Great Hall of 1503 was by far the largest banqueting hall ever built in medieval Scotland. Two high windows lit the dais on which the king and queen sat. Five enormous fireplaces provided heating. A hammerbeam roof soared above. It was a grand setting for
the sumptuous banquets of the Renaissance kings, and in particular the two royal baptismal celebrations for the sons of Mary Queen of Scots and James VI. In the latter, the fish dish came on a model ship 15′ long and 36′ high, with a salvo of 36 brass guns. As you can see from the picture of the Great Hall interior, above, to us the Great Hall really just looked like a big, empty building; it needed the pomp and glitter of tables and tapestry and roaring fires (and roaring cannon) to be impressive.
The Chapel Royal, one of the first Protestant churches built in Scotland, was built for that same baptism for the son of James VI (1594). The painted frieze in the interior survives from Charles I’s coronation visit to Scotland in 1633.
The King’s Old Building, at the castle’s highest point, was built by James IV for his private residence; the turreted staircase went to his apartment, with spectacular views. The building has endured 500 years of alterations; the right picture is an artist’s concept of what it might have looked like in the 1500’s.
Attached to this building is the Stirling Heads Gallery housing the (fabulous) original carved portraits in oak that decorated the King’s Presence Chamber (a meeting room for honored visitors) in the Royal Palace. The carvings were taken down following a ceiling collapse in 1777, and of a possible 100 original heads, 38 survive. They’re beautiful – and they’re not small, about 3 feet across. They’re divided into themes: heads of royalty (and the right to rule), “worthies” – heroes from history and myth, heads from Roman emperors, courtiers and costume, and Hercules. We’ll share a bunch, starting off
with Royalty. The heads below show courtiers wearing the (carefully depicted) fashionable
clothes of the 1540’s. A few “worthies” are shown below, and Hercules below that.
Finally, these heads were recovered with traces of paint on them. It is thought the heads were vibrantly painted, as you’ll see in more detail when we show you their reproductions in the King’s Presence Chamber (shortly). For now, let’s give you a flavor for what the heads really looked like!
To complete our visit to the Inner Close, we’ll tour the Royal Palace apartments. To mark the arrival of his (2nd) French wife, Mary of Guise, James V built the Royal Palace to be as fine a residence as Mary would have known in the richer kingdom of France. Both interior and the exterior were painted in bright colors with plenty of gilding to overwhelm with flamboyance. The 6 rooms open to the public are the king’s and queen’s apartments. Each had three spacious rooms – in ascending order of privacy: an Outer Hall‚ an Inner Hall and a Bedchamber. Access to these rooms was restricted according to the importance of the visitor. The rooms were on the same floor, arranged around a courtyard known as the Lion’s Den, and were used for a variety of purposes – taking meals, greeting important visitors, meetings on affairs of state, and dancing and entertainment. The bedchambers were rarely used for sleeping; the king and queen slept in small private chambers known as closets.
We’ll start with the King’s Outer Hall, shown above. With sufficient social standing, you would be admitted to this hall to wait for a possible audience with the king. It was a great honor to be admitted to the King’s Inner Hall, or “Presence Chamber”, shown below.
You only made it to the King’s Bedchamber (left picture) if you were really important, or a personal friend. The king probably dressed, washed and prayed here.
The Queen’s Outer Hall (below) was also a waiting room,